Brownie Batter and Peanut Butter Land Together in One Cup
Two new soft serve flavors of the week are built to be swirled into the same cup.
MAGPIES SOFTSERVE STAFFTurn your social into search
We turn your posts into editorial stories that bring new search traffic to magpiessoftserve.com. Three of yours will be on this page.
Book a demo
magpiessoftserve Remember the little bit of brownie batter left in the mixing bowl? Some of us might even admit it was better than the baked brownies, or at least that it held us over until they came out of the oven. Brownie Batter is one of our new flavors of the week, along with Peanut Butter, deep and roasted, made by folding peanut butter into our Softserve base. Get them together in one cup, and this time there's no waiting on the oven. #magpiessoftserve ##softserve #losangelesdessert
Two new soft serve flavors of the week are built to be swirled into the same cup.
MAGPIES SOFTSERVE STAFFHow it works
Same as today. Nothing changes on Instagram.
We turn your post into a full story in your voice within the hour.
One click publishes it to magpiessoftserve.com. Nothing goes live without you.
Your stories
Nothing was published anywhere. You decide that. Every word will come from your own posts, your own photos and your own menu.
New Flavors · From your post
Two new soft serve flavors of the week are built to be swirled into the same cup.
“Remember the little bit of brownie batter left in the mixing bowl? Some of us might even admit it was better than the baked brownies, or at least that it held us over until they came out of the oven. Brownie Batter is one of our new flavors of the week, along with Peanut Butter, deep and roasted, made by folding peanut butter into our Softserve base. Get them together in one cup, and this time there's no waiting on the oven. #magpiessoftserve ##softserve #losangelesdessert”
Softserve Pie · From your post
A layered slice built from blueberry pie softserve, lemon marmalade, and a brown sugar crumble is back for a short run.
“Blueberry Lemon Softserve Pie is back, in small numbers, for a short time. Blueberry Pie Softserve, lemon marmalade, lemon pound cake, blueberry jam, whipped cream, and a blueberry brown sugar crumble in a graham cracker crust. It is one of our favorite pies we make, and we only made a few, so if it has been on your list, this is the week. #magpiessoftserve #softservepie #softserveicecream #losangeles”
New flavor · From your post
A new pairing lands in the swirl, and for now you can only get it at one location.
“A new Softserve flavor, Goat Cheese & Fig. Only at Highland Park location.”
One social post becomes another searchable entry point to Magpies Softserve.
Our own magazine. Clicks and citations from Google Search Console, as of September 15, 2026.
Draft story for magpiessoftserve.com · New Flavors
Two new soft serve flavors of the week are built to be swirled into the same cup.
Two cups arrive side by side, one nearly white and swirled tall, the other a deep, glossy brown coiled just as high. They come out of the same machine but read like completely different desserts, which is the point of running flavors of the week in pairs. This one leans nostalgic on one side and rich on the other, and the pairing only works because neither flavor is trying to be neutral.
Brownie Batter is exactly what it sounds like, built around the specific memory of the bowl left behind after the pan goes into the oven. We are not talking about baked brownie pieces mixed into soft serve. We are talking about the batter itself, translated into a soft serve base, chasing that specific in between texture that is somehow better than the finished dessert it is supposed to become.
Peanut Butter is the more straightforward of the two, though straightforward does not mean simple. It is made by folding peanut butter directly into our soft serve base rather than swirling in a sauce or ribbon after the fact. That folding step matters. It spreads the peanut butter evenly through the machine so every bit of the swirl carries the same deep, roasted flavor from top to bottom instead of just the first bite.
Brownie batter and peanut butter is not a random combination. It is the flavor pairing that already exists in half the dessert recipes people grew up with, just usually separated by a baking step and a cooling rack. Here, both flavors are ready at the same time, in the same soft serve base, which means the wait that normally comes with that combination simply does not apply anymore.
Getting them together in one cup is the move worth making. Rather than choosing one flavor of the week over the other, the two can be swirled side by side, which means every spoonful can pull a little bit of both. It turns two separate flavors into one dessert instead of forcing a decision between them at the counter.
Running flavors as a rotating weekly pair keeps the base soft serve format flexible without changing what the shop is fundamentally serving. It is still the same machine, the same texture, the same tall swirl finished with that signature peak. What changes is the specific flavor folded or churned into that base, which gives regulars a reason to come back and see what is running that particular week.
There is a small logic to which flavor sits in which cup, but the more interesting choice is putting them next to each other, one pale and one dark, held out together in the same two hands. Brownie Batter and Peanut Butter were clearly meant to be ordered as a pair this week, not as two separate options competing for the same spot in a customer's hand.
Flavors of the week are temporary by design, which means the version of soft serve in these two cups will not be around indefinitely. For now, the pairing solves a very specific craving, brownie batter without the baking, peanut butter without the jar, and both without picking just one to order.
Draft story for magpiessoftserve.com · Softserve Pie
A layered slice built from blueberry pie softserve, lemon marmalade, and a brown sugar crumble is back for a short run.
Blueberry Lemon Softserve Pie is back at Magpies, but not for long and not in large numbers. We only made a few this time, which means the usual math applies: once the pans are gone, they are gone. If this pie has been sitting on your list since the last time we made it, this is the week to stop waiting and come get a slice.
The base is a graham cracker crust, the kind that holds its shape but still gives easily under a fork. On top of that sits a layer of blueberry pie softserve, dense and cold, closer in texture to a set custard than a scoop. It is the part of the pie that does the most structural work, and it is also the part that disappears fastest once you start eating.
Above the softserve comes lemon pound cake, which adds crumb and a little weight to a pie that could otherwise lean too soft. Lemon marmalade threads through that layer, sharp enough to cut against the blueberry without fighting it. The two citrus elements are doing a specific job here: keeping the whole pie from tasting like one long note of sweetness.
Whipped cream goes on next, piped rather than spread, which is part of why a cut slice holds its shape as well as it does. Under the cream and worked into the top is a blueberry jam, glossy and dark, plus a blueberry brown sugar crumble that adds the only real crunch in the whole pie. That contrast, cold and soft against crumbled and toasted, is the point.
Cut open, the slice shows its layers cleanly: purple softserve on the bottom, pale cake in the middle, white cream and dark fruit on top. Nothing here is hidden or folded in. You can see exactly what went into it before you even take a bite, which is part of why this particular pie photographs the way it does sitting on the case.
We call this one of our favorite pies we make, and we mean that as a straightforward statement, not a sales pitch. Building it in layers takes more time than a single mix, and running it in small batches is simply how we can make sure the softserve stays at the right texture and the crumble stays crisp instead of going soft under the cream.
That is also why it does not stay on the menu constantly. Small numbers for a short time is the actual plan, not a marketing line. When a batch sells through, the next one is not guaranteed to show up next week, so the gap between appearances is real and sometimes longer than people expect.
If blueberry and lemon together sound like the right combination for right now, this is the stretch of time to act on it. We are not promising a return date once this batch is finished, so treat this week as the actual window rather than a general reminder. Come by, get a slice while the crumble is still crisp, and see the layers for yourself before they run out.
Draft story for magpiessoftserve.com · New flavor
A new pairing lands in the swirl, and for now you can only get it at one location.
A new softserve flavor is running at Highland Park right now, and it pairs two ingredients that do not usually end up in the same cup: goat cheese and fig. It comes out of the machine the way our softserve always does, swirled high into a peak, pale and matte rather than glossy, with a texture that holds its shape in the cup instead of slumping.
Goat cheese is the base note here, and you can tell from the color alone that it is doing real work in the mix. Instead of the bright white of a plain vanilla base, this one leans slightly warmer and creamier, closer to the color of the cheese itself, which is usually a good sign that a flavor was built from the actual ingredient rather than an extract standing in for it.
Fig sits on top of that base rather than fighting it, which is the more interesting choice. Goat cheese on its own can read sharp or tangy, and fig tends to soften that edge without erasing it. The result is a flavor that still tastes like something with a little bite to it, just rounded out at the corners instead of left raw.
Right now this flavor is exclusive to our Highland Park location, which means the Silver Lake Reservoir spot is not running it alongside the regular lineup. That kind of single location release lets us test a flavor in a real setting before deciding whether it earns a wider run, and it gives one neighborhood a reason to stop by that the others do not currently have.
If you are used to our regular rotation, this is a departure from the more straightforward fruit and dessert flavors we usually keep in the case. Goat cheese is not an ingredient people expect to see in a softserve cup, and putting it front and center in the name, rather than hiding it behind a vaguer description, is its own kind of statement about what we think the flavor can handle.
Cheese based softserve flavors work best when the cheese is allowed to taste like cheese instead of getting buried under sugar, and the fig here reads like it is there to support that rather than mask it. Dried or cooked fig brings a jammy sweetness with texture underneath it, and that combination gives the whole cup a more layered eating experience than a single note flavor usually offers.
The cup itself is unmarked beyond our regular branding, no mix ins swirled through, no toppings pictured, so the flavor is meant to be judged on its own without distraction. That is a fairly direct way to introduce something this specific. There is nowhere for the goat cheese or the fig to hide, and nothing else in the cup to lean on if the pairing does not land.
For now, tasting it means making the trip to Highland Park specifically, since that is the only place it is being served. Flavors like this tend to function as a kind of test run, a way to see how a new idea holds up with real customers before any decision gets made about expanding it elsewhere, so this particular cup is worth catching while it is only in one place.
Keep reading